THE ABDUCTION AND MURDER OF POCAHONTAS, A True American Heroine

3g03368r1horseheader11.jpgQuite a title, huh?  However, this is exactly what the oral history of Pocahontas’s tribe, the Powhatan, teach us.  In my last blog, I tried to give an overview and an idea of how Pocahontas came to be familiar with the colonists and how they were familiar with her.  If you would like, that post is still on the blog, the date of it is March 10th and is the beginning of this post on this subject.  In my last post, I left off with Pocahontas coming of age and promised to tell you about her marriage to Kocoum, as well as her abduction by a few of the colonists and her subsequent marriage to John Rolfe.  Let’s start there.

pocanson1In the Powhatan society, a young girl and boy’s coming of age is celebrated, and it was no different for Pocahontas.  However, because there was a rumor of an abduction planned for Pocahontas, her celemony was limited to special friends and family only.  There is a special dance called the courtship dance during which male warriors searched the dancers for a mate.  This is probably where their courtship began.  After a time, they were married.smlkocoum1  Kocoum was an elite warrior.  He was among 50 of the top warriors that guarded the capital of the Powhatan confederacy.  He was also the younger brother of Wahunsenaca’s (Pocahontas’s father) friends, Chief Japazaw.  Because the priests (called quiakros) feared that the colonists plotted to kidnap Pocahontas, the couple went to live in Kocoum’s home, which was isolated from the colonists and farther north.  She was, in fact, being hidden from the English.  Kocoum and Pocahontas had a child, little Kocoum, a boy.  It was Captain Samuel Argall, an English colonist, who accomplished the feat of kisnapping Pocahontas.

3f06370r1I have to pause here to tell you of a movie I once watched where it rendered that Pocahontas and her father had a falling out and that he had banished her from the tribe, thus she had taken up with the English.  Nothing could be further from the truth.  Pocahontas was a princess, dearly loved by her father.  She was also married to Kocoum and had a child by him.  Never would she have been banished from the tribe.  That movie did nothing but further false data about this very brave woman.  But back to Captain Argall.  Why did he wish to capture Pocahontas?  Why did he take such extreme measures, for he certainly did.  Once he had learned of her hiding place, he had gathered together not only men, but weapons and arms to attempt her capture.  But why?

jsmith1Remember that the English colonists were looting the Powhatan villages of their stores of food.  They were also raping their women and children and oftentimes stealing their women and children in order to make them servants for the English.  But there was more.  The Powhatan had many diverse and rich agricultural fields. There were no trees to cut, no land to clear.  All one had to do was go in and destroy the village and take over the land — which was considered easier than clearing the land oneself.  Because of this the colonists expected retribution at any time by the very powerful tribe.  It could have happened, also.  But remember that Wahunsenaca considered the English a branch of his tribe.  Though the abuses were numerous, he still sought other ways to deal with the problem, rather than killing them outright. 

3a08570r1Through trickery and deceit, Captain Argall managed to get Pocahontas onto his ship.  She was supposed to be returned.  She never was.  She was held for ransom.  What he demanded from her father in the ransom a) the return of English weapons that had been taken from Jamestown, b) the return of the English prisoners Washunsenaca held captive and c) a shipment of corn.  Washunsenaca at once paid the ransom.  In fact Argall’s writes of the transaction in his log in 1613, “This news much grieved this great king (Wahunsenaca), yet without delay he returned the messenger with this answer, that he desired me to use his daughter well, and bring my ship into his river (Pamunkey), and there he would give me my demands; which being performed, I should deliver him his daugher, and we should be friends.”  Although Wahunsenaca quickly carried out the ransom demands, Pocahontas was never released.  images27According to the book, THE TRUE STORY OF POCAHONTAS, by Dr. Linwood “little Bear” Custalow and Angela L. Daniel “Silver Star,” “…oral history states that abefore Argall took sail (back to Jamestown), several of Argall’s men returned to Pocahontas’s home and killed her huusband, Kocoum.”  It was tradition that he would have come for her and rescued her, something that Argall could not have.  Little Kocoum survived because upon Pocahontas’s capture, he was put into the care of several of the women of the tribe.  There are still many descendents of Kocoum who are alive and well to this day.  You may again wonder why the Powhatan didn’t retaliate.  Part of that is Pocahontas’s father’s fear for her life if he did so, the other is a tribe cultural foundation of appeasing evil.  If one could, one always sought a balance between submitting to evial demands and preventing the loss of life.  Even so, the quiakros  (priests) of the tribe advised a swift retaliation, but Wahunsenaca would not do it, fearing for his daughter’s life.

pocahontas1One of Pocahontas’s elder sisters, Mattachanna, and her husband, Uttamattamakin, who was also a priest, were allowed to visit Pocahontas during her captivity.  Oral tradition is very distinct on the fact that Pocahontas confided that she had been raped and that worse, she suspected she was pregnant.  Again, rape was unheard of in Powhatan society.  Shortly after this confession, Pocahontas was quickly converted to Christianity in order to rush her into marriage.  At this time, it would have been inconcieveable for a Christian man to marry anyone who was not Christian.  It is supposed that Sir Thomas Dale was actually the biological father of Pocahontas’s child, since, according to scholars William M.S. Rasmussen and Robert S. Tilton, it was Thomas Dale who was most closely linked to Pocahontas during her kidnapping.  Note also that her son’s name was not “John,” but rather “Thomas.”  It would also explain why Rolfe (who was secretary of the colony at the time) did not record the birth of Thomas.

smlrolfe2Was the marriage one of love?  Oral history casts doubt on this.  She had just had a child, was rushed into marriage in order to make it appear that the birth had taken place after the marriage, plus she was not free to live her own life.  Did he love her?  In a letter to Dale, Rolfe refers to her as a “creature,” not a “woman.”  Regardless, they were married and Rolfe became the heir to the friendliness of the Powhatan people, which included their knowledge of the tobacco plant and how it was processed.  After all, if there weren’t gold in the New World, there had to some way to make the colony prosperous.  Rolfe had left England in 1609 with the goal of making a profit growing and processing tobacco.  He arrived in 1610 and for three years, he had been unsuccessful at both growing it and processing it.  Remember also that the year 1616 was the “deadline for the initial investments in the Virginia colony.” From the book THE TRUE STORY OF POCAHONTAS.  Time was running out.  The colony was failing.  And Rolfe’s crop was failing.

pocahont1“According to …sacred oral history, the Native people of the New World possessed the knowledge of how to cuure and process tobacco successfully.  The Spanish gained this knowledge from the Native communities they had subdued.”  THE TRUE STORY OF POCAHONTAS.  Eventually, because of Rolfe’s marriage to Pocahontas, the prists of the tribe gave him their secret.  The result was that Rolfe’s tobacco — grown on Powhatan land and cultivated by the Powhatan priests — put the Spanish taste and flavor to shame.  He was a success.  Suddenly refinancing the Virgina Company became a reality and the financial worries were over.  However, oral history also points out that the efforts of the Powhatan priests had the opposite effect of what they had hoped.  Instead of the English embracing them as brothers, it appeared that they greed was unleashed.  Tobacco became the gold of the New World.  More Powhatan lands were trespassed, killing and enslaving more Powhatan people as they did so.

350px-the_abduction_of_pocahontas1Captain Samuel Argall captained the ship taking Rolfe, Pocahontas, their son and members of the Powhatan tribe to England.  The trip had many reasons:  finances were needed to refinance Jamestown.  Approval from the public was needed.  Pocahontas provided a means to “show” the English people that the people of Jamestown and the natives were on friendly terms.  Again, Pocahontas’s sister, Mattachanna and her husband accompanied Pocahontas to England, as did several other Powhatan people.  It appeared that with so many of her own couuntrymen in tow that there was some safety.  Wisemen advised Wahunsenaca not to let her go, saying that she would never return.  But a rescue was considered too risky.

320px-baptism_of_pocahontas11It was in England that Pocahontas’s eyes were opened to the truth.  It was here that she met again and learned that John Smith was not dead.  Moreover that he had utterly betrayed her father and her people.  He had taken a solemn oath to her people to represent them to the English, and that he would bring the English under the power of the Powhatan.  She learned he had never intended to honor his word.  Pocahonta let out her rage toward Smith at their meeting.  She was not angry because of any lost love or any young girl crush on the man.  Rather she was enraged that he could so easily betray her father and her people.  It is known that with horror, Pocahontas became aware of the Englishman’s true intention toward her people: to take their lives, their lands and everything they held dear.  She longed to go home and inform her father of all she had learned.  She intended to do exactly that.

pocanson1They set sail back to England in the spring of 1617 with Samuel Argall again as the captain of the ship.  That evening Pocahontas, Rolfe and Argall dined in the captain’s chamber.  “Pocahontas quickly became ill.  She returned to her quarter by herself, sick to her stomach, and vomited.  She told Mattachanna that the English must have put something in her food.  Mattachana and Uttamattamakin tried to care for Pocahontas in her sudden illness.  As Pocahontas began to convulse, Mattachanna went to get Rolfe.  When they returned, Pocahontas had died.”  — THE TRUE STORY OF POCAHONTAS.  They hadn’t even attained open sea yet.  They were still in the river.  Rolfe immediately asked to be taken to Gravesend, where he buried Pocahontas and left Thomas there for his English relatives to take.  Rolfe never saw him again.

aa_pocahonta_newworld_3_m1Upon returning to the New World, Mattachanna and her husband, the high priest, Uttamattamakin, reported to Chief Powhatan Wahunsenaca the events in England, including the murder of his daughter.  It is from this account that the oral history has been passed down from generation to generation.  But who killed her and why?  Again, from the book, THE TRUE STORY OF POCAHONTAS, “Rolfe and the Virginia Company associates ascertained that Pocahontas knew that Smith had lied to her father and that some English businessmen were behind a scheme to remove her father from his throne and take the land from the Powhatan people.  This justified the decision by the English colonists not to take Pocahontas back to her homeland…Certain people believed that Pocahontas would endanger the English settlement, especially because she had new insights into the political strategy of the English colonists to break down the Powhatan structure, so they plotted to murder her.” 

smlrolfe2jsmith1Again, from the book, THE TRUE STORY OF POCAHONTAS, “…Dale, Rolfe, and Whitaker had close ties to each other.  All three had major roles in what happened in Pocahontas’s life after she was abducted.  Dale eventually took custody of Pocahontas after Argall took her to Jamestown.  Whitaker maintained Pocahontas’s house arrest and surveillance.  All three sought to convert Pocahontas to Christianity.  Rolfe married Pocahontas. Dale provided a large tract of land for Rolfe to grow tobacco.  A Dale-Rolfe-Whitaker trio comprising agreements and pacts is not out of the realm of possibility, but … sacred oral history does not reveal who or how many persons were behind her murder.  We believe it is most likely that more than one person was involved.”

So ends my story of the abduction and murder of a true heroine.  A heroine because she tried to unite two different peoples.  A heroine because she endured much, all to help her people.  She did it with little complaint, though it goes without saying that she yearned for the company of her own people, her own little son and the husband of her heart, Kocoum.smlpocwn1  It’s not exactly the Disney or fairytale story that we’ve all been spoon-fed.  However, it shows the courage and persistence of a young woman who did all she could to help her father and her people.  She is a true American heroine.

Well, there you have it.  What do you think?  It’s doubtful Hollywood would make a movie of this story, though I wish that they would.  But this is the story that has been passed down from generation to generation amongst the Powhatan people and their various tribes, specifically the Mattaponi.  For further information, I would highly recommend the book, THE TRUE STORY OF POCAHONTAS by Dr. Linwood “Little Bear” Custalow and Angela L. Daniel “Silver Star.”  Read it for yourself and come to your own conclusions.  It is a story or oral tradition.  It is not a made-up story. 

So come on in and let me know what you think of this.  Leave a comment, if you please.

Website | + posts

KAREN KAY aka GEN BAILEY is the multi-published author of American Indian Historical Romances. She has written for such prestigious publishers as AVON/HarperCollins, Berkley/Penguin/Putnam and Samhain Publishing. KAREN KAY’S great grandmother was Choctaw Indian and Kay is honored to be able to write about the American Indian Culture.
Please refer to https://petticoatsandpistols.com/sweepstakesrules for all contest rules.

34 thoughts on “THE ABDUCTION AND MURDER OF POCAHONTAS, A True American Heroine”

  1. Hello Karen,

    I have been waiting for the second part of this blog which seems like it took forever. I thought it would never get here. Thank you for such a wonderful and enlightening blog. Even though the oral rendition is tragic, I feel it is a blessing in disguise. We need to hear and learn the true history of our nation not just the good stuff.

    Have a great day.

  2. Every time I think we’ve come to a new low in this world of how badly people treat each other, something like this comes along and I know there’s nothing new under the sun.

    To think they’re trying to convert her to Christianity, the very men who rape her and her people and kill her husband and steal from her…hello…three commandments right there…well four…coveting your neighbor’s stuff…five…wait…six.

    It is confusing to say the least, how they justified their lives.

  3. How enlightening, Kay. A very sad story about a beloved heroine. I can’t imagine how horrible it would be to be taken from everyone I loved and to suffer such atrocities. Thank you for sharing this true account. I’m always learning something new.

  4. Hi Roberta!

    Exactly. How can we learn from history, is all we get is a sugar-coated false picture of the entire thing?

    History should be a study of causes and effects, something the leaders of our countries sometimes forget. : )

  5. Oh, Mary, thank you so much for bringing this up. It violates so many commandments. Greed…it does seem to do things to those who are not very strong in spirit.

    Thanks Mary!

  6. Hi Linda,

    Thank you so much for your comments and for reading this. I know it’s sad. But history is there for a reason. How can we learn if we don’t see the causes and effects?

    Anyway, thanks again.

  7. Just wanted to say what a wonderful job you have done with this. You must have a very strong spirit to overcome such horrible things. You explain it so well.
    Thanks for sharing Kay

    Melinda

  8. Hi Kay, I was riveted by this post and definitely will read her “True Story.” I had no suspicion of her murder or Smith’s betrayal or marriage and son prior to Rolfe. Wow.

    I recently did a blog on Chief Joseph at my publisher blog and am ever aware of the horrific things done to the native peoples. As a child in history class, I was taught that “manifest destiny” was our right. How WRONG!

    Thanks for this wonderful information.

    oxoxoxoxo

  9. Hi Kay, thanks so much for this bit of history. It is a sad story but I love hearing the real truth about things. Thanks for sharing this story with us.

  10. And we called the Indians savages. What man is capable of doing to one another still stuns me.

    As to the tobacco – IMO I find it poetic justice that it’s killed more “Americans” than they ever could have.

    Thanks for the real history lesson.

  11. Hi Tanya!

    Like you, I wanted to do the post to bring about the truth about this very brave heroine. There’s so much false information out there — almost like propaganda…again, I think history is there to show causes and effects — this cause created this kind of effect. I think if we actually did teach history this way, we’d not have any more wars. : )

    Thanks Tanya!

  12. Hi Jeanne!

    Like you, I am stunned — and continue to be stunned by the hatred that can be put about man to man — and how greed can bring about terrible things for those whose soul is weak.

    Maybe we should try to make people stronger so that they don’t fall to the evils of greed.

    Thanks for your comment.

  13. My counsel: pray for all the peoples of the world
    that love and caring for each other will prevail!

    Pat Cochran

  14. Hello Kay, I finally got on the blog on the right day. Thank you so much for that full story about Pocahontas. I was anxiously awaiting the continuation. What a sad commentary on the “White Eyes,” as the Apache called them, treatment of the first real Americans. Your research is commendable. I enjoyed reading it, even if it was heartbreaking at the same time.

    Love you, Carol Ann

  15. Ahhh yes the wonderful world of empire building, driven by greed and lust for what someone else has. Taken by superior might and questionable morals. I think the English and especially the Financial Elite behind all of the war mongers over the last several centuries have taught the world a rather grusome lesson, now if the people of the world will just wake up to this lesson and throw the Financial Elitist out this would be a much happier world. Thanks for posting this story. It is great to learn the truth.
    Much Love, your hubby soapboxing again.

  16. Hi Carol,

    Thank you so much for making it to the forum today. Not a good commentary or a good way to start — deception from the beginning — however, if we know history and understand it, perhaps we can learn from it instead of repeating the same old errors over and over and over.

  17. Oh, Paul, how well you put that, my darling husband. And while we’re at it, let’s throw the henchmen out with the bathwater…psychiatry — which has used what it knows to betray mankind with electric shocks, chemical lobotomies, brainwashing and now their ‘gift’ to mankind, psychotropic drugs that cause our children to want to commit murder or to kill themselves. Every shooting that has happened on this subject has been from someone either on or just coming off these psychotropic drugs. So let’s throw them out as well, okay?

  18. Part two was worth waiting for. Sad how easy it is for some people to feel they are better than others. By considering others less worthy or less human, they can and have justified many evils. It is too bad that we are not teaching much in history today. Some states don’t go any futher back than WWII in American history. It is shameful how ignorant of even recent events many are. It doesn’t help that what they often hear isn’t even true (example: poor General Custer and his men, ambushed by those terrible indians. Yeah, right.). We can’t learn from history if we don’t know it as it truely happened. Thanks for a very good mini history lesson.

  19. Thanks for the alternative version, but I’m troubled by the uncritical acceptance of the murder allegation as ‘truth’ seeing as it is based on nothing but hearsay (an oral tradition received from people that were on the other side of the Atlantic and whose tradition could not possibly be based on anything but speculation).
    Replacing the ‘Indians as monsters’ narrative with the ‘English as monsters’ narrative does not seem like much progress to this observer.

  20. I am glad the truth is told. This is how Pocahontas wanted to be heard. The bad men had silenced her voice by poisoning her meal.
    I remember hearing a story about a man who was dead for 41 hours and then came back from the dead. He told people that angels took him to both heaven and hell.
    In hell, he saw pastors who stole money and saw others gnashing in torment. Angels explained that they went to hell because they stole land from other peoples. So, yeah, I believe that whoever killed Pocahontas & her people ended up in hell.
    For more info, go to:
    http://bibleprobe.com/ekechukwu.htm

  21. I think this is probably the most accurate of all the Pocahontas histories I have read. Sadly the story does not end well for the Princess, and we must wonder what differences there would be today had she not have been killed and allowed to raise her son here among here people. The mistreatment of the Powhatan people and kidnap, rape, and murder of Pochantos was a grave wrong doing and travesty. None the less it is history. The truth should always be told. The good honored and the wrongs placed where they belong. There is no way we today can right such a wrong. In my view, what matters most is to better educate this nation and others on the true story of an Princess and Heroine and her people. And before we condemn others, let us remember we still don’t have the facts; nor do we know what is really the truth.

  22. I am also pleased that the people have finally let the truth be known. As an ancestor of Pocahontas, I was sad to hear this repetitive story of the white man and his devious methods of undermining a peaceful people for avarice and greed. It reminds me to be leery of much of our so-called history in this country. I now have more love and respect for this brave young woman than I did before I read this. I am sure she would never have done anything to deceive or hurt her people. She was little more than a pawn to be used and then murdered by her captors, including her “beloved” John Rolfe. What a shame.

  23. Professional Towing Services For Fast And Easy Towing Solutions In Your Town.What other towing company give you a deal like this before you’ve even called in an emergency? Whether you need a wheel lift tow truck or a flat bed, you can always expect to get what you need at an affordable price. Some of the other services that they offer are car towing, long distance towing, towing Service, SUV towing, motorcycle towing, automobile towing, tow truck rollback, equipment transport towing and more. It doesn’t matter whether you’re locked out of your car, flat tire or your car just won’t start. we got your back, call us today.

  24. In the words of manual

    That’s a bunch of bull shit

    They should be given all they land back

Comments are closed.